When credit card rewards aren't worth the fees or the interest

3 min read General education, not advice

Credit card rewards aren't worth it when the interest on a balance you carry, or the card's annual fee, costs more than the rewards you earn. Card APRs are far higher than rewards rates, so even a modest balance can cancel out a year of cash back.

The simple test

Add up what a card pays you in a year. Then subtract what it costs you over the same year: the annual fee, the interest, and any other fees such as late fees or foreign transaction fees.

If the answer is above zero, the rewards are paying you. If it's below zero, the card is costing you money, whatever the rewards rate says.

Worked example: carrying a balance

These are round numbers for illustration. Your own will be different.

Say you spend $1,000 a month on a card that pays 2% cash back. That's $20 a month, or $240 a year.

Now say you also carry a $3,000 balance at a 24% APR. That works out to about 2% a month, so roughly $60 a month in interest, or about $720 a year.

In this example you'd earn $240 and pay about $720, leaving you about $480 behind. If you paid the full statement balance every month instead, you'd keep the $240 and owe no interest on purchases, as long as the card has a grace period.

Worked example: an annual fee

Say one card has no annual fee and pays 1.5% on everything. Another charges $95 a year and pays 3% on groceries.

The second card earns 1.5 percentage points more on groceries. To cover the $95 fee with that extra 1.5%, you'd need to spend about $6,333 a year on groceries, or about $528 a month. Below that, the fee card leaves you with less. That's before counting any lower rate it pays outside groceries.

If your grocery spending is closer to $300 a month, the extra rate earns about $54 a year. The fee takes all of that and another $41.

Other ways rewards end up costing you

  • Buying things you didn't plan on to earn rewards. A 2% reward on a $100 purchase you didn't need still leaves you $98 down.
  • A late payment can bring a late fee and, on some cards, a penalty APR. Either can wipe out months of rewards.
  • Cash advances usually don't earn rewards, and they come with their own fee and a higher APR.
  • On a card with a foreign transaction fee of around 3%, a 1% or 2% reward on purchases abroad doesn't cover the fee.
  • Rewards that expire, or that you lose when you close the account, are worth nothing.

When rewards do come out ahead

Rewards tend to pay off when you pay the full statement balance every month and the card's categories match where you already shop. Any annual fee should be covered by what you'd earn at your normal spending, with room to spare.

If you often carry a balance, the APR matters more than the rewards rate when you compare cards. The CFPB's credit card guides explain how interest and fees are charged.

Run your own numbers

  1. Total the rewards you earned over the last 12 months, using your statements or the card's rewards page.
  2. Add up the interest and fees you paid over the same months. Your statements show year-to-date totals for both.
  3. Subtract the costs from the rewards.
  4. If the result is negative, paying down the balance will save you more than any rewards rate can earn.

This guide is general education, not financial advice. Card rates, fees and approval are set by each issuer, so check the issuer's own terms before you apply.

Get the newsletter

Plain-English tips on credit cards and credit, plus card offers from our partners. Free.

More guides

Cash back basics

How cash back rewards actually work

Earning rates, bonus categories, caps and redemption rules, and what decides how much cash back you really get from a card.

4 min read