Rewards vs card fees: how much you'd need to spend to break even
To find how much you'd need to spend for rewards to cover a card's fees, divide the yearly fees by the rewards rate. At 1.5% back, a $150 annual fee takes $10,000 of spending a year, or about $833 a month, just to break even. If the alternative is a no-fee card that also pays rewards, divide by the extra rate only, and the number gets much bigger.
The basic formula
Break-even spending is your yearly fees divided by the rewards rate, written as a decimal. These examples use made-up fees and rates:
- A $150 fee at 1.5% back: $150 divided by 0.015 is $10,000 a year.
- A $75 fee at 1% back: $75 divided by 0.01 is $7,500 a year.
- A $120 fee on a card paying 3% on groceries: $120 divided by 0.03 is $4,000 a year of grocery spending, before counting anything the card pays on other purchases.
Below the break-even point, the card costs you more than it pays back. Above it, the rewards come out ahead, as long as you don't pay interest.
Count every fee you'd pay
The card's rates and fees table lists its fees. Under Regulation Z, the table in a card application or offer has to show any annual or other periodic fee, how often it's charged and the yearly amount. Add up the costs that apply to you:
- The annual fee. The CFPB notes that some issuers charge it in monthly installments, so a monthly fee times 12 is the number to use.
- Foreign transaction fees, if you use the card for purchases abroad.
- Late fees, if a payment has ever slipped.
- Interest on any balance you carry. The CFPB has found that cardholders who carry a balance from month to month pay 94% of all card interest and fees, but get less than 30% of the rewards.
Comparing a fee card with a no-fee card
The basic formula tells you when a fee card beats having no rewards at all. If the alternative is a no-fee card that also pays rewards, the fee has to be covered by the extra rate alone.
These numbers are made up. Say a card with a $150 annual fee pays 2% on everything, and a no-fee card pays 1.5%. The fee card earns 0.5 percentage points more, so $150 divided by 0.005 is $30,000 a year, or $2,500 a month, before the fee card comes out ahead.
At $1,500 a month, or $18,000 a year, the fee card earns $360 and the no-fee card earns $270. Take off the $150 fee and the fee card leaves you with $210, which is $60 less than the no-fee card.
Category cards work the same way, one category at a time. Our guide to flat-rate vs category cash back shows how to total a mix of rates.
First-year offers
If a card has no fee in its first year or pays a sign-up bonus, both help in year one only. Run the numbers for year two as well, when the fee is charged and there's no bonus. Our guide to sign-up bonuses covers the conditions that come with them.
Benefits that aren't cash back
The CFPB notes that for cards with high annual fees, much of the appeal comes from extra benefits, such as access to events or airport lounges. Count a benefit only at what it would save you, based on what you'd actually use and would otherwise pay for. A benefit you never use is worth nothing in this math.
Run your own numbers
- Add up 12 months of spending you'd put on the card, split by category if the card's rates differ.
- Work out the rewards at each rate, counting any caps.
- Subtract every yearly fee and any interest you'd likely pay.
- Do the same for the card you'd use instead, and compare the two totals.
Our guide to when rewards aren't worth it has more worked examples with interest.
Common questions
How do I count a monthly fee?
Multiply it by 12 and treat it like an annual fee. A $10 monthly fee is $120 a year, which takes $8,000 of spending at 1.5% to cover.
Does the break-even change if I carry a balance?
Yes. Add the interest to the fees. With a $150 fee and $300 of interest in a year, a card paying 1.5% needs $30,000 of spending just to break even.
Is a card with an annual fee ever worth it?
It can be, when your normal spending is well above the break-even point against the card you'd use instead, you'd use any extra benefits, and you pay the full balance each month.
The CFPB's guide to finding the best credit card for you suggests comparing the rewards you expect to get and use each year with the annual fee.
This guide is general education, not financial advice. Card rates, fees and approval are set by each issuer, so check the issuer's own terms before you apply.
Get the newsletter
Plain-English tips on credit cards and credit, plus card offers from our partners. Free.